Metal vs Plastic Hose Reel Box: Which One Should You Choose?
When it comes to storing your garden hose, the storage box you choose matters more than you might think. Two of the most popular options on the market are metal hose reel boxes and plastic hose reel boxes. Both have their merits — but which one is right for your garden?
In this guide, we break down the key differences so you can make the best decision for your outdoor space.
1. Durability: Metal Wins for Long-Term Use
Metal hose reel boxes — especially those made from heavy-duty weather-resistant steel — are built to last. They can withstand UV rays, rain, frost, and physical impact far better than most plastic alternatives. Plastic boxes, while lightweight, can crack, fade, or warp over time when exposed to prolonged sunlight and temperature swings.
Winner: Metal — especially if you live in a region with harsh summers or cold winters.
2. Aesthetics: Metal Looks More Premium
Metal cabinet hose reels have a classic, structured look that complements most garden and patio styles. The slatted metal design gives a clean, organized appearance that plastic boxes often can't match. If curb appeal matters to you, metal is the clear choice.
Winner: Metal — for a tidier, more decorative outdoor aesthetic.
3. Weight & Portability: Plastic Is Lighter
If you need to move your hose reel frequently — between the front yard and backyard, or indoors for winter storage — plastic boxes are significantly lighter and easier to carry. Metal boxes, while sturdy, can weigh 20–30 lbs depending on the model.
Winner: Plastic — for portability and frequent relocation.
4. Price: Plastic Is More Budget-Friendly
Plastic hose reel boxes are generally less expensive upfront. However, if a plastic box cracks or fades within a few seasons, you may end up spending more in the long run replacing it. Metal boxes cost more initially but often prove to be the better investment over time.
Winner: Plastic (short-term) / Metal (long-term value)
5. Weather Resistance: Metal Holds Up Better
Quality metal hose reel boxes are designed to handle all-weather conditions — working temperatures typically range from 23°F to 104°F (-5°C to 40°C). While plastic can become brittle in freezing temperatures, a well-coated metal box maintains its structural integrity season after season.
Winner: Metal — for year-round outdoor use.
6. Assembly: Both Are Straightforward
Both metal and plastic hose reel boxes typically require some assembly. Metal boxes may require an electric drill and pliers, while plastic models often use snap-fit or hand-tightened connections. Neither is particularly difficult — most setups take 10–20 minutes.
Winner: Tie
So, Which Should You Choose?
Here's a quick summary to help you decide:
- ✅ Choose Metal if you want long-term durability, a premium look, and all-weather performance.
- ✅ Choose Plastic if you need something lightweight, portable, and budget-friendly for occasional use.
For most homeowners who want a reliable, attractive hose storage solution that lasts for years, a metal hose reel box is the smarter investment.
Our Recommendation
The Relhost RW-24 Metal Cabinet Hose Reel Box is a heavy-duty, weather-resistant metal cabinet that holds up to 125ft of standard garden hose. It's free-standing (no wall mounting required), available in Brown and Dark Gray, and built to last through every season.
- Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
